By: Rafeeat Bishi
The video on the Apu character from The Simpsons prompted some thinking. Hari Kondabolu made very good points as to why certain humor can not be brushed off as "jokes"
Today, people are becoming more comfortable with speaking out against offensive comments. However, when most marginalized groups bring this up, they're seen as easily offended and sensitive. I don't think it's "sensitive" to not appreciate rude comments.
It wasn't funny when Kevin Hart said he'd beat his child for being gay. What's funny about child abuse? His homophobia is the butt of the joke, and there's nothing funny about hating a group of people for existing.
Kondabolu made me think a lot about satire. By definition, satire is "the use of humor, irony, exaggeration, or ridicule to expose and criticize people's stupidity or vices, particularly in the context of contemporary politics and other topical issues".
The show Boondocks is the perfect example. When Riley makes homophobic jokes or Uncle Ruckus makes completely racist comments, it's seen as funny and humorous because of how outrageous they are. They, like many other characters in the show, represent exaggerated versions of the black community. Riley is the impressionable, homophobic, toxic masculinity black male, and Uncle Ruckus is the self-hating black male. They're offense is the essence of their characters, which is why most gay people would not have problems with Riley's jokes. They're not the butt of the joke. He is.
IF Apu's character was written to ridicule those who make outrageous assumptions about South Asian people, or to criticise the system that makes it harder for brown immigrants to achieve success, then it would be satire. But we don't. Apu is a character we only see through the eyes of the Simpsons, and they are not once criticised for their own biases. He's not given depth, or dimension. He stands there for comedy, not to offer South Asians good representation. There's even more issues in the fact that a white actor voiced him. How would he know Apu's experience?
Like that man said in the video (which Kondabolu made a good point shooting down) Comedy is supposed to stem from conflict. What's funny about the conflict of Apu's situation? The fact that there's a chance he'll stay at that store to support his family for the rest of his life? That's not biting satire or humor. Its bullying.
The next time someone ridicules a culture or makes jokes about lifestyles, I hope one considers the nuances of what they're saying. Be wary of the groups affected by your "jokes".